The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[casi] Army Drs Refuse Burned Children Treatment

Hearts and minds, eh? f.

Published on Monday, June 23, 2003 by the Associated Press
Burned Iraqi Children Turned Away By US Army Doctors
by Donna Abu-Nasr

BALAD, Iraq - On a scorching afternoon, while on duty at an Army airfield,
Sgt. David J. Borell was approached by an Iraqi who pleaded for help for his
three children, burned when they set fire to a bag containing explosive
powder left over from war in Iraq.
Borell immediately called for assistance. But the two Army doctors who
arrived about an hour later refused to help the children because their
injuries were not life-threatening and had not been inflicted by U.S.
Now the two girls and a boy are covered with scabs and the boy cannot use
his right leg. And Borell is shattered.
"I have never seen in almost 14 years of Army experience anything that
callous," said Borell, who recounted the June 13 incident to The Associated

U.S. military policeman Sgt. 1st Class Brian Pacholski, left, comforts his
hometown friend, U.S. military policeman Sgt. David J. Borell, right, both
from Toledo, Ohio, at the entrance of the U.S. military base in Balad, about
50 kilometers (30 miles) northwest of Baghdad, Friday, June 13, 2003. Borell
broke down after seeing three Iraqi children who were injured while playing
with explosive materials. (AP Photo/Victor R. Caivano)
A U.S. military spokesman said the children's condition did not fall into a
category that requires Army physicians to treat them  and that there was no
inappropriate response on the part of the doctors.
The incident comes at a time when U.S. troops are trying to win the
confidence of Iraqis, an undertaking that has been overwhelmed by the need
to protect themselves against attacks. Boosting security has led to
suspicion in encounters between Iraqis and Americans. There are increased
pat-downs, raids on homes and arrests in which U.S. troops force people to
the ground at gunpoint  measures the Iraqis believe are meant to humiliate
In addition, Iraqis maintain the Americans have not lived up to their
promises to improve security and living conditions, and incidents like the
turning away of the children only reinforce the belief that Americans are in
Iraq only for their own interests.
For Borell, who has been in Iraq since April 17, what happened with the
injured children has made him question what it means to be an American
"What would it have cost us to treat these children? A few dollars perhaps.
Some investment of time and resources," said Borell, 30, of Toledo, Ohio.
"I cannot imagine the heartlessness required to look into the eyes of a
child in horrid pain and suffering and, with medical resources only a brief
trip up the road, ignore their plight as though they are insignificant," he
Maj. David Accetta, public affairs officer with the 3rd Corps Support
Command, said the children's condition did not fall into a category that
requires Army doctors to care for them. Only patients with conditions
threatening life, limb or eyesight and not resulting from a chronic illness
are considered for treatment.
"Our goal is for the Iraqis to use their own existing infrastructure and
become self-sufficient, not dependent on U.S. forces for medical care,"
Accetta said in an e-mail to AP.
The incident came to light after an AP photographer took a picture of Borell
being comforted by a colleague after the doctors refused to care for the
children. When Borell's wife, Rachelle Douglas-Borell, saw the photo, she
contacted AP with a copy of a letter he sent her describing what happened.
When Borell talks about the children, he pauses between sentences, keeps his
head down, clears his throat.
Seated on a cot in a bare room at an Army air base in Balad, 55 miles
northwest of Baghdad, Borell said when he saw the three children, especially
the girls, Ahlam, 11, and Budur, 10, he visualized his daughters, Ashley, 8,
and Brianna, 5.
Borell, who spoke to the family through an Iraqi bystander with some
English, did not understand exactly what happened to the children.
But the children's father, Falah Mutlaq, told AP they set fire to a bag of
explosives they found on a street in their village, Bihishmeh, a few miles
from the base.
Mutlaq, 36, who has 14 children from two wives, said he took the children to
a hospital in Balad, but they were turned away because the facility could
not treat them. He then took them to the base.
Borell's eyes cloud with pain when he describes the children.
Madeeha Mutlaq was holding her son, Haidar, 10, fanning him with a piece of
cardboard. His legs, arms and half of his face were singed. Ahlam, Haidar's
full sister, and Budur, his half-sister, had fewer but still extensive
What struck Borell was the children's silence.
"They did not utter a single sound," he said.
Borell radioed his superiors, who contacted the base hospital.
Two Army doctors, both of them majors, responded.
One of them, according to Borell, "looked at (Haidar) ... didn't examine
him, didn't ask him questions."
"(He) never looked at the girls," said Borell.
"Through the interpreter, one of the doctors told the father that we didn't
have any medicine here ... and were not able to provide them care," said
Borell. "And he also expounded on the fact that they needed long-term care."
Borell said the combat hospital was fully stocked.
"Right before they left, I looked at the one doctor, asked him if he could
at least give them comfort care," said Borell. "He told me they were not
here to be the treatment center for Iraq."
"He didn't show any compassion," the sergeant added.
Borell grabbed his first-aid kit and gave the father some bandages and IV
solution to clean the wounds.
Mutlaq, who grows oranges and apples with water he gets from the Tigris
River, laughed when he recalled the doctor's words.
"He lied," Mutlaq said. "The world's greatest power going to war without
burn medicine? Who can believe that?"
Mutlaq took the children the next day to Baghdad for treatment.
Budur, a chubby, giggly child with light brown eyes, seems to have recovered
except for a large scab on her right arm.
Ahlam and Haidar are covered with yellowish scabs scattered over raw red
flesh. Haidar keeps his left fingers bent and hops on his left leg because
it's too painful to use the right one. A smile rarely leaves his face
despite the discomfort.
Mutlaq said he often hears the children whimper at night from the pain.
Despite their suffering, Mutlaq said he feels no bitterness.
"How can I not love the Americans? They helped me with a flat tire the other
day," he said.
Borell said he felt betrayed by the Army, which he joined after high school.
Besides the letter to his wife, he also wrote to his congresswoman and
several media outlets describing the incident.
His superiors have not said a word, said Borell, "although I get the
impression that they're probably not very happy."
Borell's wife gave him a silver bracelet that says: "Duty, Honor, Country."
He wears it to remind him why he's in Iraq.
"After today, I wonder if I will still be able to carry the title 'soldier'
with any pride at all," said Borell.
Copyright 2003 The Associated Press

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]