The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[casi] More from Laurie Mylroie

[ Presenting plain-text part of multi-format email ]
U.S. Suspects Al Qaeda Got Nerve Agent From Iraqis
Analysts: Chemical May Be VX, And Was Smuggled Via Turkey
By Barton Gellman
Washington Post Staff Writer
Thursday, December 12, 2002; Page A01
The Bush administration has received a credible report that Islamic
extremists affiliated with al Qaeda took possession of a chemical weapon
in Iraq last month or late in October, according to two officials with
firsthand knowledge of the report and its source. They said government
analysts suspect that the transaction involved the nerve agent VX and
that a courier managed to smuggle it overland through Turkey.
If the report proves true, the transaction marks two significant
milestones. It would be the first known acquisition of a nonconventional
weapon other than cyanide by al Qaeda or a member of its network. It
also would be the most concrete evidence to support the charge, aired
for months by President Bush and his advisers, that al Qaeda terrorists
receive material assistance in Iraq. If advanced publicly by the White
House, the report could be used to rebut Iraq's assertion in a
12,000-page declaration Saturday that it had destroyed its entire stock
of chemical weapons.
On the central question whether Iraqi President Saddam Hussein knew
about or authorized such a transaction, U.S. analysts are said to have
no evidence. Because Hussein's handpicked Special Security Organization,
run by his son Qusay, has long exerted tight control over concealed
weapons programs, officials said they presume it would be difficult to
transfer a chemical agent without the president's knowledge.
Knowledgeable officials, speaking without White House permission, said
information about the transfer came from a sensitive and credible source
whom they declined to discuss. Among the hundreds of leads in the Threat
Matrix, a daily compilation by the CIA, this one has drawn the kind of
attention reserved for a much smaller number.
"The way we gleaned the information makes us feel confident it is
accurate," said one official whose responsibilities are directly
involved with the report. "I throw about 99 percent of the spot reports
away when I look at them. I didn't throw this one away."
Like most intelligence, the reported chemical weapon transfer is not
backed by definitive evidence. The intended target is unknown, with U.S.
speculation focusing on Europe and the United States.
At a time when President Bush is eager to make a public case linking
Iraq to the United States's principal terrorist enemy, authorized
national security spokesmen declined to discuss the substance of their
information about the transfer of lethal chemicals. Those who disclosed
it have no policymaking responsibilities on Iraq and expressed no strong
views on whether the United States should go to war there.
Even authorized spokesmen, with one exception, addressed the report on
the condition of anonymity. They said the principal source on the
chemical transfer was uncorroborated, and that indications it involved a
nerve agent were open to interpretation.
"We are concerned because of al Qaeda's interest in obtaining and using
weapons of mass destruction, including chemical, and we continue to seek
evidence and intelligence information with regards to their planning
activity," said Gordon Johndroe, spokesman for Homeland Security
Director Tom Ridge. Johndroe was the only official authorized by the
White House to discuss the matter on the record.
"Have they obtained chemical weapons?" Johndroe said. "I do not have any
hard, concrete evidence that they have." Pressed on whether the
information referred to a nerve agent, Johndroe said "there is no
specific intelligence that limits al Qaeda's interest to one particular
chemical or biological weapon over the other."
One official who spoke without permission said a sign of the
government's concern is its "ramping up opportunities to collect more,
to figure out what would be the routes, where would they be taking the
material, how would they deploy it, how are they transporting it, what
are the personnel?" The official added: "We're not just sitting back and
waiting for something to happen."
A Defense Department official, who said he had seen only the one-line
summary version of the chemical weapon report, speculated that it might
be connected to a message distributed last week to U.S. armed forces
overseas. An official elsewhere said the message resulted only from an
analyst's hypothetical concern.
Prepared by the Defense Intelligence Agency, last week's "Turkey Defense
Terrorism Threat Awareness Message" warned of a possible chemical
weapons attack by al Qaeda on the Incirlik Air Base in southern Turkey.
Incirlik is an important NATO facility from which a U.S.-led coalition
in 1991 launched thousands of bombing runs to force Iraq to withdraw its
army from Kuwait. Turkey has given conditional agreement to its use in
the event of a new war with Iraq.
According to two officials, a second related threat report was
distributed in Washington this week. The CIA message, transmitted before
the daily 3 a.m. compilation of the Threat Matrix, described a European
ally's warning that the United States might face a chemical attack in a
big-city subway if war breaks out with Iraq. A U.S. government spokesman
said the European ally offered little evidence and "the credibility of
the report has not been determined."
Among the uncertainties about the suspected weapon transfer in Iraq is
the precise relationship of the Islamic operatives to the al Qaeda
network. One official said the transaction involved Asbat al-Ansar, a
Lebanon-based Sunni extremist group that recently established an enclave
in northern Iraq. Asbat al-Ansar is affiliated with Osama bin Laden's al
Qaeda organization and receives funding from it, but officials said they
did not know whether its pursuit of chemical weapons was specifically on
al Qaeda's behalf.
The government is also uncertain whether the transaction involved a
chemical agent alone or an agent in what is known as a weaponized form
-- incorporated into a delivery system such as a rocket or a bomb. The
latter would be a more efficient killer, but chemical weapons are deadly
in either form. Among the reasons for suspecting VX was involved is that
it is the most portable of Iraq's chemical weapons, capable of
inflicting mass casualties in a quantity that a single courier could
After initial denials, Iraq admitted in the 1990s that it had
manufactured tons of VX and two less sophisticated nerve agents, Sarin
and Tabun. Its remaining chemical arsenal was limited to blister agents,
such as mustard gas, that date back to World War I.
First developed as a weapon by the U.S. Army, VX is an oily, odorless
and tasteless liquid that kills on contact with the skin or when inhaled
in aerosol form. Like other nerve agents, it is treatable in the first
minutes after exposure but otherwise leads swiftly to fatal convulsions
and respiratory failure. The United States, a signatory to the Chemical
Weapons Convention, destroyed the last of its stocks of VX and other
chemical agents on the Johnston Atoll, 825 miles southwest of Hawaii, in
November 2000.
U.S. military forces, hazardous materials teams and some ambulance
systems carry emergency antidotes. They usually come in autoinjectors
containing atropine and an oxime -- drugs that reverse the neuromuscular
blockade of a nerve agent. Atropine-like drugs have other uses, such as
in anesthesia and in treating cardiac arrest, and are often stocked in
During inspections by the U.N. Special Commission, or UNSCOM, in the
1990s, Iraq denied producing any chemical weapon other than mustard gas.
Faced with contrary evidence, it eventually acknowledged the manufacture
of 3.9 tons of VX and 3,859 tons in all of lethal chemicals. The Baghdad
government also admitted filling more than 10,000 bombs, rockets and
missile warheads with Sarin. It denied having done so with its most
potent agent, VX, but an international commission of experts assembled
by UNSCOM said the scientific evidence suggested otherwise.
UNSCOM said in its final report, in January 1999, that it could not
account for 1.5 tons of the VX known to have been produced in Iraq, and
that it could not establish whether additional quantities had been made.
The U.N. Security Council ordered Iraq in April 1991 to relinquish all
capabilities to make biological, chemical and nuclear weapons as well as
long-range missiles. The declared basis for the present threat of war is
the U.S. view, shared by the Clinton and Bush administrations, that the
Baghdad government never came close to complying.
In 1998, the Clinton administration asserted that Iraq provided
technical assistance in the construction of a VX production facility in
Sudan, undertaken jointly with al Qaeda. In retaliation for al Qaeda's
August 1998 truck bombings of U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania,
President Bill Clinton ordered the destruction of the al Shifa
pharmaceutical plant in Khartoum, Sudan's capital.
Clinton's advisers released scant public evidence about al Shifa, and
the Tomahawk missile attack was widely regarded as a blunder. Top
Clinton administration officials, and career analysts still in
government, maintain there was strong evidence behind the strike but
that it remains too valuable to disclose. During last year's New York
trial of the embassy bombers, prosecution witness Jamal Ahmed al-Fadl, a
onetime operative who broke with al Qaeda, offered limited
corroboration. He named al Qaeda and Sudanese operatives who had told
him they were working together to build a chemical weapons plant in
Khartoum. He said nothing about Iraqi support for the project and named
a site near, but not in, the al Shifa plant.
Only once has a chemical weapon been used successfully in a terrorist
attack. During the morning rush hour on March 20, 1995, the Japanese
cult Aum Shinrikyo placed packages on five subway trains converging on
Tokyo's central station. When punctured, the packages spread vaporized
Sarin through the subway cars and then into the stations as the trains
pulled in.
In all, the Sarin contaminated 15 stations of the world's busiest subway
system, putting 1,000 riders in the hospital and killing 12 of them.
Though the attack spread great terror in Japan, it took fewer lives than
its authors expected because the Sarin reached many victims in a form
that was not sufficiently concentrated.
"Psychologically, use of nerve agent in the United States would send
people over the deep end, but it probably wouldn't kill very many
people," said an official whose responsibilities have included the
assessment and disruption of the threat.
Others said the panic induced could have serious economic consequences,
rendering many Americans unwilling to enter a facility of the sort that
had suffered a chemical attack.
In general, al Qaeda's pursuit of chemical and biological weapons is
well known to U.S. intelligence. A central player in the effort has been
Midhat al Mursi, an Egyptian who is among the most-wanted al Qaeda
operatives but who remains at large. He ran a development and testing
facility for lethal chemicals in a camp -- in Derunta, Afghanistan --
that was eventually renamed "Abu Kebab" after Mursi's nom de guerre.
The Derunta operation is not thought to have progressed beyond
unsophisticated poisons, including the cyanide used in videotaped
experiments on dogs. Unconsummated plots by al Qaeda and its allies in
Jordan just before the turn of the millennium, and in Britain last
month, also involved cyanide.
C 2002 The Washington Post Company

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]