The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[casi] Iraqi Council Flexes Muscles -- LATimes

[ Presenting plain-text part of multi-format email ]

>From ppg

Mon Dec 29, 3:51 AM ET
By Carol J. Williams Times Staff Writer


Iraqi Council Flexes Muscles
BAGHDAD - Seen by a distrustful public as a tool of the occupying powers, Iraq 's Governing Council 
is coming of age on the job as it tries to define a leadership to take over from the United States 
and its allies.

But as the 25-member body steers Iraq toward sovereignty, promised in a mere six months, it is 
acting like a defiant adolescent, challenging the authority and wisdom of those who gave it life. 
And its bargaining position has been strengthened by the Bush administration's apparent eagerness 
to declare its mission accomplished before the U.S. presidential election.

No longer the passive instrument that U.S. civilian administrator L. Paul Bremer III used to carve 
the contours of a new Iraq, the council has become increasingly assertive, demanding control of the 
reconstruction purse strings and the authority to supplant Bremer's vision with its own.

Council members complained that fledgling Iraqi security forces were not given the financial 
support or authority needed to combat insurgents. They prevailed in getting U.S. assurances that 
war crimes suspects - jailed former leader Saddam Hussein  first among them - will be handed over 
to Iraqis for prosecution, despite pressure from some American circles to try them in an 
international forum.

On Monday, the council signed three mobile telephone service licenses, ignoring a Pentagon  probe 
into allegations of corruption made by U.S. and Turkish companies that had been unsuccessful 

The council began flexing its muscles last month when it undertook a review of Bremer's 
gubernatorial appointments to each of Iraq's 18 provinces. It deemed four of the governors unfit 
for office, firing one and starting procedures to replace the others. Council members are 
challenging such regional appointments by Bremer, insisting they are better acquainted with the 
needs and values of Iraqis than an American making personnel choices under deadline pressure.

Bremer wants the council to knuckle down to the task of drafting a Fundamental Law that will guide 
the country through 2005, by which time a constitution should have been drafted and ratified in a 
referendum and direct national elections scheduled to let Iraqis choose their new leaders. The 
council has only until Feb. 28 to deliver the complex law that will lay out electoral and governing 
procedures for the Transitional Assembly that will assume power from the coalition.

Instead, the council has delved into staffing the provincial governments. "The Americans can't give 
the right judgments about our governors. We have to get that from the people in the street," said 
Ahmad Shyaa Barak, a Shiite lawyer on the council.

"The provincial councils will play a big role in selecting the next leaders. It is not acceptable 
that they were appointed," Barak said.

"We must make the necessary changes. It's too important, regardless of the objections of the" 
U.S.-led Coalition Provisional Authority.

Bremer initially overruled the council's November firing of Babylon Gov. Iskandar Jawad Witwit on 
grounds of corruption. But Bremer let stand a second council edict on Dec. 9 dismissing Witwit for 
membership in the outlawed Baath Party.

The coalition apparently calculated that to oppose the council would contradict the aims of the 
"de-Baathification" process as well as reinforce an impression among many Iraqis that the council 
is a puppet of the occupying powers. However, instead of placating the council, the battle 
emboldened it to insist on replacing other officials.

"Some of those appointed are not working out. They were bad choices," argued Mahmoud Othman, a 
Sunni Kurd and a political independent. "After the war, things were done in a hurry. We have to 
make corrections before the next elections."

Coalition officials are reluctant to publicly discuss what remains a behind-the-scenes clash over 
the appointments. One said only that probing regional councils would be time-consuming, and in the 
absence of reliable public opinion research, it would be difficult to accurately gauge any interim 
governor's real standing with constituents.

_____Some council members suspect the coalition authority is protecting a few malleable governors 
so they can place figures in the next executive who otherwise might be unable to garner local 
support. For example, the Pentagon's favorite ally on the council, Ahmad Chalabi, lived outside 
Iraq for 35 years and has no support base in the country.____

Initially in lock step with Bremer on the shape of a future Iraq, the council has increasingly 
asserted its autonomy on financial and judicial affairs as well as appointments.

The council has won assurances that Hussein will be turned over to Iraqi custody to face trial here 
on war crimes. Council members have also dismissed allegations that the U.S. occupiers will wield a 
heavy hand in shaping the newly created Iraqi war crimes tribunal.

"The justices will be appointed by the Governing Council, not the CPA," said Dara Noureddine, a 
former judge on the council who was jailed by Hussein for refusing to overturn a ruling against the 

Other council members have become resentful, at least in private, over Washington's hurry-up 
campaign to extract itself from Iraq while refusing to relinquish power to the new Iraqi 

"We feel very strongly that it is unfair to expect a process that needs two to three years to be 
done properly to be squeezed into six months," one council member said. "But we have to agree to 
this. It's a little 'thank you,' the least we are expected to do for a man who liberated 25 million 

While the council appears ready to accept Bremer's conclusion that direct elections for the next 
leadership bodies are impossible due to time constraints, the proposed caucus system continues to 
be looked at askance by Iraq's most powerful religious leader, Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani. His 
threat to denounce the caucus method as illegitimate would probably dissuade many Shiites, who 
constitute more than 60% of the Iraqi population, from participating in the process.

Mouwafak Rabii, a Shiite council member and British-educated physician, insists that the leadership 
body taking over from the council in six months will have more credibility because it will be 
selected in a broadly representative forum.

Like most council members, Rabii believes the current leaders are not only eligible to run for the 
new positions but their experience with the initial phase of self-rule uniquely qualifies them for 
the next transitional team.

"They should play a pivotal role in the next leadership. They have expertise and experience," Rabii 
said of his fellow council members. "You need continuity. We can't have this idiotic American 
system of dumping everyone from their positions when a new president wins election."

He agrees that the council has become more assertive as it evolves and predicts that Bremer and the 
Pentagon architects of the emerging Iraq will have to give way to Iraqis' own vision.

"We started off wobbly," Rabii said. "It was a new experience for us. We didn't understand the 
concept of trading off. Compromise is a dirty word in Arabic."

He bridles under criticism aired by Bremer in Washington last month that the council has been too 
slow to work through the tasks assigned it: appointing Cabinet ministers, ratifying budgets for 
2003 and 2004, representing Iraq abroad, building up Iraqi security forces and starting work on a 
new constitution.

"We've done all of that. Where are the shortcomings?" the former exile said. "And we have done all 
this under occupation, when the CPA has ultimate authority, not us. If anybody has failed, it is 
the occupational authority."

Nasir Chaderchi, a Sunni member of the council, warns that poor investment in Iraqi security forces 
could delay the hand-over of sovereignty and departure of U.S. forces.

"The Americans have done nothing to give the Iraqi institutions more authority," said Chaderchi, 
the head of the National Democratic Party. "The Interior Ministry can't hire one single policeman 
now because of an alleged lack of funds."

Meanwhile, negotiations are underway between the Pentagon and the council on the number of troops 
that will stay on after July 1 and the powers they will have, council member Adnan Pachachi said.

"What is important is that they will then be here with our approval and under conditions on which 
we've agreed," said Pachachi, who at 80 is the oldest and most respected member of the council. "We 
will no longer have occupational forces."

Iraqis want a minimal foreign presence but fear they will be vulnerable to tribal and sectarian 
rivalries and attacks by foreign forces unless they have in place a well-trained police force, 
civil defense corps, border guards and standing army.

All those forces are being built up now, but their numbers remain a fraction of what both the 
occupiers and the occupied said would be needed.

In Baghdad, for instance, 7,500 police have been hired while the capital's population needs 20,000.

"If the Americans want to leave, they have to first build up our security forces," said Chaderchi, 
one of the few council members with no plans to run for parliamentary or executive office in the 
upcoming caucuses.

"For the time being we are too weak. Foreign terrorists can easily make Iraq their base. But all 
these problems could be resolved quickly if our coalition partners would remove the roadblocks."


 Speaking of Ahmed Chalabi, the following quote from WSWS:

"..The restoration of the telephone system has been further delayed by a Pentagon investigation 
into the awarding of phone licenses to Iraqi Governing Council member and US stooge,  Ahmed 

The entire quite informative article is found at  "Nine months after US invasion: Fuel shortages, 
blackouts heighten Iraqi opposition to American occupation"  December 29  

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]