The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[casi] "Why do they treat us like cattle?"
Toronto Star
Aug. 10, 2003

What language is U.S. speaking in Iraq?
By Haroon Siddiqui, editorial page editor emeritus.

One cringes on hearing some Americans analyze non-Americans.

Here is Lt.-Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, chief commander in Iraq, announcing the
curtailment of U.S. raids in the futile search for Saddam Hussein, Baathists
and other troublemakers  raids that have alienated Iraqis because troops
were often ending up at the wrong address due to faulty intelligence:

"We created in this culture some Iraqis that then had to act because of
their value systems against us in terms of revenge, possibly because there
were casualties on their side and also because of the impact on their
dignity and respect."

Set aside the awkward lingo. The message is clear enough:

Iraqis are resisting the occupation not because innocent bystanders are
getting killed or injured in ill-conceived and ill-executed American

Nor because doors to people's homes are being kicked down in the middle of
the night, their meagre possessions turned topsy-turvy and their cash,
essential for survival in the absence of banks, seized.

Nor because men are being dragged out in pyjamas, gagged and detained in
frequent cases of mistaken identity; women are having their privacy invaded
by aggressive and foul-mouthed strangers; and children are being frightened
and psychologically scarred.

No, none of that, said the general, but because Iraqi culture and custom
dictate they act up under such circumstances!

What planet do these Americans live on? Or are they so preoccupied spinning
propaganda that they have no sense of reality? Or is it that they just don't
care what anyone thinks beyond their core constituency of fellow citizens
and foreign fellow travellers?

So monumental has the mismanagement of post-Iraq been that essential
services and law and order are still not back to pre-war levels. Looting has
given way to carjacking and kidnapping.

Iraqi frustrations over rampant crime have the eerie echo of women in
U.S.-controlled Afghanistan who lately have been complaining that, under the
Taliban, they were at least safe from rape.

The Americans are operating in chaotic conditions under which many are
getting killed. But they have contributed to the chaos by being ill-prepared
for post-war Iraq, by being culturally clueless and trigger-happy.

After all, the British  in charge of Basra and other southern areas  are
doing a far better job of managing the supposedly far more troublesome

American haplessness can be seen in their guesswork on who might be
attacking them: "Saddam Fedayeen, displaced Baathists, some Islamic
extremists, the so-called Army of Muhammad, Wahhabis, maybe some Al Qaeda
terrorists, Iranian-backed Shia  who knows?" said Maj. Scott Sossaman, a
battalion leader, in a typical comment.

The bombing of the Jordanian embassy in Baghdad Thursday had the stamp of Al
Qaeda terrorism. If so, the Americans have been going after the wrong people
on false assumptions and weak intelligence.

The latter emanates from too much reliance on technology and on "experts,"
in Iraq and back in Washington, who speak no Arabic and have little or no
feel for the pulse of the land or its people.

Beyond the house raids, Americans have angered Iraqis by detaining about
5,000 people, many on the flimsiest of suspicion, for weeks.

They're being held under inhumane conditions, with no opportunity to get
word back to their families.

French and British media are reporting from the notorious Abu Ghraib prison,
once again in use, and from other detention centres.

Detainees are held under "tarps surrounded by barbed wire under blistering
sun," says the Liberation of Paris Web site (

It quotes one as saying that prisoners are punished at the slightest
infraction and "made to stand for hours in the sun, arms and legs

Others are said to be "thrown in the dirt on their stomach, with their hands
tied, under the hot sun."

Amnesty International has just condemned such American abuses. Ironic, since
the liberators are ostensibly there to establish democracy and the rule of

Then there's the callous or casual American approach to collateral damage
caused in the hunt for Saddam or by measures to subdue the resistance.

Between six to a dozen bystanders were gunned down during a wild, and
unprovoked, shootout by the elite Task Force 20 during a recent raid in
Baghdad in pursuit of him.

Sixteen were killed in the April bombing of a restaurant where he was
supposed to be.

We don't know how many died in the cruise missile attack on "a Saddam
bunker" on the eve of the war.

Seymour Hersh of The New Yorker magazine has just revealed that 80 innocent
people were killed in a June 28 raid near the Syrian border on a convoy that
was thought to be carrying Saddam and his entourage.

American soldiers have killed more than 30 people by firing on demonstrators
in Baghdad, Falujah, Mosul and Karbala.

How many dead Iraqis, soldiers and civilians, during the war and since its
end May 1?

No one knows for sure. Or cares. Not the U.S. military. As Gen. Tommy Franks
said, "We don't do body counts"  of the enemy. Not the American media,
either. They don't even seem to make an effort.

According to, run by academics and peace
activists, the reported civilian death count, so far, stands at "a minimum
of 6,087 and a maximum of 7,798."

The estimated number of injured is 20,000.

American forces have been given the benefit of the doubt because they've
been facing guerrilla attacks. But their actions and, in fact, their entire
approach to the occupation raise disturbing questions, summarized in what
Iraqis most often ask visitors: "How do Americans think of us, as Iraqis or
as animals? Why do they treat us like cattle?"

Haroon Siddiqui is the Star's editorial page editor emeritus.


Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]