The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[casi] Liberation update: 'Bremer is Ba'athist ..'

Not much change in press freedom either .... f

Published on Thursday, June 19, 2003 by the Boston Globe
US Restrictions on Iraqi Media Spark Criticism
by Ellen Barry

NAJAF, Iraq -- Coalition soldiers raided the distribution center for
Sadda-al-Auma newspaper last week, seizing extra copies of its second
edition and detaining and interrogating its employees, said staff at the
Nevertheless, Sadda-al-Auma, or The Echo of the Nation, was back on the
newsstands with a third edition on Tuesday, selling its pungent brand of
postwar analysis: Its front page invited the people of Najaf to join the
Ramadi resistance movement; warned that Zionist groups were commandeering
some of Baghdad's best real estate; and damned unveiled women for their
''stinking, Western ideas,'' asking, ''Is this liberty, to walk around

Members of the political party The Highest Council To Liberate Iraq
demonstrate in Najaf, Iraq, against the shutting down of their newspaper The
Eco of the Nation Friday June 13, 2003. The fledgeling newspaper was shut
down by US occupation forces on June 12 for alleged incitement to violence
against the Coalition Forces. (AP Photo/Denis Doyle)
Last week the US-led coalition authority brought a strong hand down on the
hurly-burly collection of new voices that have cluttered Iraqi newsstands,
virtually absent of any advertising, since Saddam Hussein fell. The new law
bans incitement of violence against American troops or against any
religious, ethnic, or gender group, and prohibits any publication that
promotes a return of Saddam Hussein's Ba'ath Party.
US officials insist the law applies only to material that undermines civil
order that is necessary for a free and democratic Iraq and that it is meant
to prevent violence.
''It's not designed to be restrictive,'' said Charles Heatly, a coalition
spokesman. ''We welcome the emergence of a free press, and we have no
intention of stifling free speech.''
The act, which carries fines and prison sentences, has spawned resentment
among members of the new media class, who argue that newspapers restrained
from criticizing the American forces hardly constitute a free press.
''Would you agree to be constrained by a decision of President Bush?'' asked
Mohammed Abdul Hadi, whose organization, the Supreme Council to Liberate
Iraq, helps publish and distribute Sadda-al-Auma. ''Why do you apply these
constraints on Iraq when they are not applied on Americans?''
Not everyone in Najaf complained about the new regulations, though. In Al
Nawras Publication House, whose stock has skyrocketed from four newspapers
to 140, Adnan al-Sudani said the press freedom has gone too far already,
allowing unqualified people to disseminate misinformation. Although his
sales have gone up 70 percent, Sudani said the content has begun to worry
''Iraq has reached the limits of democracy in journalism,'' he said. The
Iraqi reader ''is like a thirsty man in the desert. When he gets water, he
starts drinking and drinking and never fills his thirst.''
Until two months ago, Iraqi readers had two print news sources to choose
between: Al Thaura, or The Revolution, and Al Jamorriya, which translates as
The Republic. Both featured Hussein on the front page every day, and they,
like television news, fell under the tyrannical watch of Uday, the
president's oldest son. All that control broke suddenly in April, when
Hussein's government collapsed under the US-led invasion.
In Baghdad, the new regulations infuriated some editors.
''Freedom of expression . . . includes the freedom of a citizen or a
journalist to criticize the presence of foreign forces on its land,'' said
Shehab al-Tamimi, an official in the Iraqi Journalists' Syndicate. ''It is
the right of the Iraqi people to express everything they believe.''
On the front page of yesterday's edition of As'saah, or The Hour, a masthead
editorial explained that two articles had been spiked before deadline out of
concern about punishment by the Americans.
The editorial, headlined ''[Ambassador L. Paul] Bremer is a Ba'athist,''
read, in part: ''Only four months ago, the easiest accusation to make
against us was that we were agents for America. Today, with the same ease,
they put sacks on our heads and accuse us of being agents for Saddam Hussein
and the Ba'ath Party.''
The editorial continued: ''There is nothing worse than Saddam Hussein except
what we are suffering now, and I hope I will not be surprised tomorrow
morning by your soldiers surrounding my building.''
Bremer is the top American administrator in Iraq.
The case of Sadda-al-Auma was already well known in Najaf, where the banned
edition sold like hotcakes after the American raid. The newspaper is
published by the Supreme Council to Liberate Iraq, a political organization
which Hadi said developed in the marshes of southern Iraq during the
uprising against Saddam Hussein in 1991.
Ali Chiad, a 32-year-old guard at the building, said he had been detained,
bound, and held for four days while American interrogators asked his
superiors questions about the newspaper. He said bags were put over the
captives' heads and that troops seized the excess copies of Sadda-al-Auma.
Hadi expects the paper to keep publishing unless coalition forces ban the
At his newsstand where newspapers sell for pennies, Sudani said he doubted
that the American penalties were compelling enough to stop the profusion of
new messages.
''Already we have an undertaker and an estate broker and a marsh-man
publishing newspapers. We are waiting for the butcher to take part,'' said
Sudani. ''The butcher and the cab driver.''
 Copyright 2003 Globe Newspaper Company.

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]