The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[casi] Red Cross Denied Access To PoWs

Red Cross denied access to PoWs
Up to 3,000 Iraqis - some of them civilians - believed to be gagged, bound, hooded and beaten at US 
camps close to Baghdad airport
Ed Vulliamy in Baghdad
Sunday May 25, 2003
The Observer,6903,963108,00.html
The United States is illegally holding thousands of Iraqi prisoners of war and other captives 
without access to human rights officials at compounds close to Baghdad airport, The Observer has 

There have also been reports of a mutiny last week by prisoners at an airport compound, in protest 
against conditions. The uprising was 'dealt with' by the Americans, according to a US military 

The International Committee of the Red Cross so far has been denied access to what the organisation 
believes could be as many as 3,000 prisoners held in searing heat. All other requests to inspect 
conditions under which prisoners are being held have been met with silence or been turned down.

There is circumstantial evidence that prisoners are being gagged and hooded, in the manner of the 
Afghans and other captives held at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba - treatment in itself questionable under 
international law.

Unlike the Afghans in Cuba, there is no doubt about the status of these captives, whether PoWs or 
civilians arrested for looting or other crimes under military occupation: all have the right, under 
the laws of war, to be visited and documented by the International Red Cross. 'There is no argument 
about the situation with regard to the Iraqi armed forces and even the Fedayeen Saddam,' said the 
ICRC's spokeswoman in Baghdad, Nada Doumani.

'They are prisoners of war because they have been captured during a clear conflict between two 
states. If they served in the armed forces or in a militia with distinctive clothing which came 
under the chain of command of one of the warring states, they are protected under article 143 of 
the Geneva Convention.'

The ICRC has gained access to prisoners held in camps at Umm Qasr in the south. But with regard to 
the larger numbers reportedly held in Baghdad, said Doumani, 'we are still waiting for the green 
light, more than a month after the end of the conflict. This is in breach of the third Geneva 
Convention.' She said the laws of war should give the ICRC access 'as quickly as possible'.

The airport camps are also said to contain many hundreds of civilians detained for looting, who, 
Doumani said, 'do not fit into the category of prisoners of war, according to the Americans'.

Civilians held, she said, have similar rights because they have been detained by an occupying 
power, which the ICRC insists the Americans to be, even if they do not use those words of 

'Civilian prisoners under a military occupation have the right to be visited and documented,' she 
said, 'and for their next-of-kin to be informed. Hundreds of families are looking around Baghdad 
for members of their families who have gone missing and are believed to have been arrested. They 
are being taken somewhere, but no one knows where.'

A US military source said a mutiny occurred at the beginning of last week at one compound at the 
airport zone - for the most part a sealed-off area and the site of some of the heaviest civilian 
casualties as the Americans surged into the Iraqi capital.

The rebellion was 'dealt with' by the US authorities, said the source, with no confirmation or 
denial of deaths.

Witnesses to the camps are few, since no Iraqi prisoners taken to them have been released. But a 
cameraman for the France 3 television channel, arrested at the Palestine Hotel, did manage a 
glimpse. Leo Nicolian has documentation signed by a Lieutenant Brad Fisher saying he was wrongly 
arrested (and beaten, with a black eye to prove it) for the alleged theft of a bag from an American 

He was held at the tennis court compound along with, he said, about 50 other prisoners, and told he 
was detained 'for investiga tion'. On his way out, Nicolian said he passed a bigger encampment in 
which he saw 'hundreds of men' hooded, with their arms tied behind their backs.

A worker for a non-governmental aid organisation, who asked not to be named, told The Observer that 
he saw men in a similar state aboard a truck, apparently in transit from one place to another. The 
aid worker said he managed to video the scene.

Doumani said there was no specific wording in the Geneva Convention on the American practice of 
hooding and gagging, but that the law did specify that prisoners be treated humanely. 'We have to 
assess what is humane,' she said.

Guardian Unlimited  Guardian Newspapers Limited 2003

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]