The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]


Wonderful work, glen!
The Mirror's story:;


Exclusive By Gary Jones And Alexandra Williams In Los Angeles

JOURNALIST Sean Boyne and student Ibrahim al-Marashi have attacked Tony
Blair for using their reports to call for war against Iraq.

Mr Boyne, who works for military magazine Jane's Intelligence Review, said
he was shocked his work had been used in the Government's dossier.

Articles he wrote in 1997 were plagiarised for a 19-page intelligence
document entitled Iraq: Its Infrastructure Of Concealment, Deception And
Intimidation to add weight to the PM's warmongering.

He said: "I don't like to think that anything I wrote has been used for an
argument for war. I am concerned because I am against the war."

The other main source was a thesis by post-graduate student, Ibrahim
al-Marashi, the US-born son of Iraqis, who lives in California. His research
was partly based on documents seized in the 1991 Gulf War.

He said: "This is wholesale deception. How can the British public trust the
Government if it is up to these sort of tricks? People will treat any other
information they publish with a lot of scepticism from now on."

After the dossier's origins were revealed, Mr Blair was accused by his own
MPs of theft and lies. The fiasco has deeply damaged his attempts to win
backing for military action.

It emerged the PA to Mr Blair's spin chief Alastair Campbell was involved in
drawing up the dossier which was published last month.

Alison Blackshaw and a Government press officer were both named on the
dossier when it was first put on the Government's website. But the names
were later removed.

The bulk of the Government's document is directly copied, without
acknowledgement, from Ibrahim's 5,000-word thesis - Iraq's Security and
Intelligence Network - published last September.

He did not even know the dossier existed until Glen Rangwala, a
Cambridge-based Iraq analyst, spotted the plagarism and called him.

Ibrahim, whose parents fled to the US from Iraq in 1968, said the Government
not only blatantly lifted much of his work, including typing and grammatical
errors. Mr al-Marashi and Mr Boyne said their figures had been altered in
the Government document.

Former Labour Defence Minister MP Peter Kilfoyle said: "It just adds to the
general impression that what we have been treated to is a farrago of

"I am shocked that on such thin evidence that we should be trying to
convince the British people that this is a war worth fighting."

And Labour MP Glenda Jackson said: "It is another example of how the
Government is attempting to mislead the country and Parliament.

"And of course to mislead is a Parliamentary euphemism for lying."

The PM's official spokesman rejected Ms Jackson's claims but admitted it had
been a mistake not to acknowledge Mr al-Marashi's thesis in the dossier.

He added: "The fact we used some of his work doesn't throw into question the
accuracy of the document as a whole. This document is solid."

Asked whether Downing Street was embarrassed about the affair, the spokesman
said: "We all have lessons to learn."

The dossier had been praised by US Secretary of State Colin Powell in his
speech to the UN Security Council. Mr Boyne added: "Maybe I should invoice
Colin Powell."

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]