The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [casi] FW: Lest we forget...

I would like to know if this book, published by the Baghdad Observer, has a chapter on Helebje or 
the Anfal military campaign !
Alternatively, was there any criticism of the powers that be for supplying the technology for WMD ?
                  M A

>>> "farbuthnot" <> 10/07 12:38 pm >>>

George Jr.'s Band is swinging satellite photos and testimonies from
transfuges to convince the US and the world that there is a
justification for attacking Iraq, already a victim of Western genocide.
It would be good to not lose sight of  history.

I am posting a couple of texts, written at or around the time of the
first US war against Iraq, show how that war was prepared and how the
peoples of the world misled. They are simply to refresh our memories of
how we got into this mess. Today we can use the power of historical

TITLE: How Washington manufactured a war crisis*
AUTHOR: Huda M. al-Yassiri
DATE: 8/5/1996
PUBLISHER: The Baghdad Observer

CONTENTS: (...) Late in January, Channel 4 of the British TV broadcast a
documentary showing how American news consumers were dazzled and deluded
by manipulators of satellite photos of Kuwait taken five weeks after
August 1990 to justify the deployment of US troops to Saudi Arabia,
al-Jumhuriya daily newspaper reported.

(...) The article, "Public doesn't get picture with Gulf satellite
photos," said when president George Bush began his massive deployment of
American troops to the Gulf in August 1990, he claimed that Iraq, which
had just entered Kuwait, had set its sights on Saudi Arabia. On
September 11, 1990, Bush addressed a joint session of Congress, saying,
"We gather tonight witness to events in the Gulf as significant as they
are tragic. 120.000 Iraqi troops with 850 tanks had poured into Kuwait
and moved south to threaten Saudi Arabia".

On January 6, 1991, however, Jean Heller reported in the St. Petersburg
(Fla.) Times that satellite photos taken the same day that president
Bush addressed Congress failed to back up his claim of an imminent Iraqi
threat. In fact, there was no sign of a massive Iraqi troops buildup in

Heller told "In These Times," The troops that were said to be massing on
the Saudi border and that constituted the possible threat to Saudi
Arabia that justified the US sending of troops do not show up in these
photographs. And when the Department of Defense was asked to provide
evidence that would contradict our satellite evidence, it refused to do

(...) Heller said in her story that Soviet satellite photos taken five
weeks after August 2, 1990 suggest that the Bush administration might
have exaggerated the scope of Iraq's military threat to Saudi Arabia at
the time.

The photos are not conclusive proof that the administration
overestimated Iraq's buildup along the Saudi border, a buildup that was
cited as a justification for the deployment of US troops. But two
American satellite imaging experts who examined the photos could find no
evidence of a massive Iraqi presence in Kuwait in September 1990.

(...) A Soviet commercial satellite took a photo of Saudi  Arabia on
September 11, 1990 and a photo of Kuwait on September 13. At the time,
the Defense Department was estimating there were as many as 250.000
Iraqi troops and 1.500 tanks in Kuwait. The photos were obtained by the
St. Petersburg Times in late December 1990.

(...) The mystery surrounding the numbers of Iraqi troops first surfaced
in November, 1990, after ABC News purchased several Soviet satellite
photos of Kuwait taken on September 13, 1990 and could find no evidence
of large numbers of Iraqi troops.

(...) The Times bought the missing photos of Kuwait, as well as a photo
of part of Saudi Arabia, from Soyuz-Karta, a Soviet commercial satellite
agency that sells pictures worldwide for such purposes as geological
studies and energy exploration. The cost was $ 1.500 a photo.

The Times retained two satellite image specialists to interpret the
photos: Zimmerman, a nuclear physicist who now is a professor of
engineering at George Washington University in Washington D.C, and a
former image specialist for the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) who
asked not to be named because of the classified nature of his work.

While Iraqi troops cannot be seen, it is easy to spot the extensive
American military presence at the Dhahran Airport in Saudi Arabia.

"We could see five C-141s one C5A and four smaller transport aircraft,
probably C-130s," said Zimmerman. "There is also a long line of
fighters, F-111s or F-15s on the ground. In the middle of the airfield
are what could be camouflaged staging areas.

"We did not find anything of that sort anywhere in Kuwait. We do not see
any tent cities, we do not see congregations of tanks, we do not see
troops concentrations, and the main kuwaiti air base appears deserted.
It's five weeks after August 2, 1990, and what we can see, the Iraqi air
force has not flown a single fighter to the most strategic air base in

There is no infrastructure to support large numbers of (military)
people. They have to use toilets, or the functional equivalent. They
have to have food. They have to have water at the rate of several
gallons per man per day. They have to have shelter. But where is it?".

(...) The troops could have been so well camouflaged that they were
hidden from the Soviet cameras. However, Zimmerman said that would be a
departure from Iraq's strategy during its war with Iran in the 1980s
when virtually no effort was made to hide military positions. Both
analysts recall seeing Iraqi troops deployments during that war on
poorer images from the French SPOT satellite.

It's also possible that the troops were so widely dispersed that the
satellite could not "See" them because its cameras could not resolve
images smaller than five meters, or about 16 feet, across. Or it might
be that glare from the sun on the Kuwaiti sand smudged out troops
images, although images taken over Saudi Arabia appear unaffected by

(...) On September 18, 1990 only days after the Soviet photos were
taken, the Pentagon said Iraqi forces in and around Kuwait had grown to
360.000 men and 2.800 tanks, a move of troops and equipment sizable
enough to leave telltale marks on the landscape that should be visible
by satellite.

(...) A satellite photo of the same area of kuwait on August 8, just a
few days after Iraqi troops entered Kuwait, shows some sand cover on the
roads, Zimmerman said, and the cover appeared to be less extensive,
suggesting that it continued to build up over the next month.

"It certainly indicates that nobody's been driving over them and that
the (Iragi) military has not bothered to clear them for traffic, he
said". Asked if the Defense Department officials could dispel the
mystery created by the Soviet photos, Pentagon spokesman Hall replied:
"There is no mystery as far as we are concerned. They (the Iraqi troops)
are there. We would like it to remain a mystery what our intelligence
capabilities are. We are not going to make our intelligence public".

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:


London Borough of Hackney may exercise its right to intercept any communication
which you send to, or receive from, any employees or agents of the Council using
its telephony/data networks. By so communicating you give your consent to
London Borough of Hackney monitoring and recording any use of these networks.

Please contact the sender if you have received this e-mail in error.

The Data Protection Officer, London Borough of Hackney, Hackney Town Hall, Mare
Street, London E8 1EA

Sent via the discussion list of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.
To unsubscribe, visit
To contact the list manager, email
All postings are archived on CASI's website:

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]