The following is an archived copy of a message sent to a Discussion List run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

Views expressed in this archived message are those of the author, not of the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq.

[Main archive index/search] [List information] [Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Wellington Quakers' Statement

Media Statement regarding the United States attacks on
Wellington Quakers Peace and Public Questions Committee

"We utterly deny all outward wars and strife and fightings with
outward weapons, for any end or under any pretext whatsoever."
Quaker Declaration to Charles II, 1661.

Wellington Quakers Peace and Public Questions Committee call for
an immediate end to the United States attacks on Afghanistan.

We are sure that such military actions will exacerbate and not
solve the problem of why the World Trade Centre and the
Pentagon were attacked. We say this because it seems certain
that the attacks on the United States were mainly in response to
the means by which they have pursued their political and economic
objectives in many parts of the world.

Iraq is a current example, with around 1,500,000 deaths due
almost entirely to the destruction by United States forces in 1991
of practically the entire civilian infrastructure. That destruction
was planned to achieve the results we see today. The misuse of
the "dual use" clause by the United States in the Sanctions
Committee has added to the suffering.

A completely unacceptable aspect of the bombing of Afghanistan,
apart from its already having caused civilian deaths and injuries, is
that it is causing hundreds of thousands of already poverty-
stricken and hungry people to leave their homes and seek asylum in
neighbouring countries. This does not appear to be consistent with
Article 2141 of the United Nations Charter which requires that
force shall not by used in any manner that is inconsistent with the
purposes of the United Nations.

We agree with United Nations staff (and the Médecins Sans
Frontieres) involved in famine relief in Afghanistan who say that
the United States offer of "aid" is merely a political ploy, and if a
major disaster is even to be minimised the United Nations aid
programme must be allowed to go ahead unhampered either by
bombing or by token aid dropped inaccurately from military

We point out that, while the United Nations Charter allows states
to act in self-defence, Article 33 requires that parties to a
dispute shall first of all seek a solution by negotiation, inquiry,
mediation, conciliation, arbitration judicial settlement, resort to
regional agencies, or other peaceful means. Not until all such
means are exhausted can force be used. The dispute in this case is
that the Taliban will not accede to United States demands that
they surrender Osama bin Laden to them.

We draw attention to the following report:
"UNITED NATIONS, Oct 6 (IPS) - The overriding messages from
this week's General Assembly debate over terrorism are that
retribution should be secondary to building a global anti-terrorism
alliance that addresses the causes of violence - and that this
alliance should be led by the United Nations, not the United

We are happy for NZ to engage in United Nations-approved, truly
international policing actions to deter world terrorism, and we
hope that we may play our part in international mediation.

We do not want New Zealand to be engaged in a war controlled
and managed by the United States against whichever unfortunate
nations are named as their enemies at the time.

The United States' best friends are those who will tell them that
their only real means of defence will be, (1) to cease their own
acts of terrorism, (2) to begin to make amends for the damage
done, (3) to bring criminal acts of terrorism to justice through
legal channels (we are heartened in this regard to note Britain's
recent decision to ratify the International Criminal Court treaty).

We want to say to the United States that such military
interventionism as has been practised by them and other States,
has no place in a world seeking ways to live amicably and without

Tony Maturin,
4 Hoggard St,.

For Wellington Quakers Peace and Public Questions Committee.

This is a discussion list run by the Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq
For removal from list, email
CASI's website - - includes an archive of all postings.

[Campaign Against Sanctions on Iraq Homepage]